“Judge a man by his questions rather than by his answers.” -Voltaire
Just last month, my husband (we’ll call him MB) and I were in Paris during the train (SNCF) strikes. During this strike something like 2 out of every 3 trains was cancelled and we arrived at the Paris Gare de Lyon to find that our train back to Grenoble had been one of the unlucky ones. After talking to multiple SNCF staff, it was explained that they could not issue us new tickets as ours were not exchangeable but we could board the next train with our old tickets and we were “sure” to get a seat. My reaction was something like this:
Uh, I’m sorry, what? You are not going to issue another ticket? I’m just supposed to take a chance that what you are suggesting will work out and that we’ll manage to get two randomly free seats in the middle of 3 train’s worth of people trying to board?!?
Oui, apparently that is exactly what we were supposed to do.
So we sat and we waited, having no idea whether or not we would manage to get on the following train that was leaving in 3 hours. As the minutes ticked by, my anxiety grew, I was practically bouncing around with nervous energy. What if we didn’t get on, what was the plan then? Would we stay in Paris for the night? Did I need to start calling friends to try and find a place to crash? Maybe we should just take the hit and purchase brand new tickets? The uncertainty was making me crazy but to my surprise, when I looked around the jam-packed train station, most people seemed pretty zen.
“It’s amazing,” I said. “How is everyone so calm and quiet when no one knows what is going on? In the U.S. people would be flipping out or commiserating with strangers or…flipping out*.”
MB looked around and thought for a second or two. “Maybe we are just more philosophical.”
I do not deal well with change.
Now, I don’t mean change as in: “if only women hadn’t gotten the vote” way, but rather: “what do you mean we’re going out to dinner tonight?” When I have organized or arranged something and it changes at the last minute, my brain slams into overdrive, regardless of whether this is a positive change or not.
It goes something like this:
Stage 1: Panic.
OHMEGAWD, what is happening? I’m spinning in circles? Why? I don’t know. It doesn’t matter anyway, there is no rhyme or reason to anything in the world. Apparently, things just happen…(this thought then creates further panic)
Stage 2: Doomsday.
Well, it’s all over. I might as well just sit down. I mean, why do I even try anymore? Nothing will ever work out the way it is supposed to…EVER. Life is just one ironical joke.
Stage 3: Recalibration.
Stage 4: Epiphany/denial.
Phew…well, lookie-there, the perfect solution just presented itself. In fact, this option is actually better than the original plan anyway. Things always just fall into place, it’s a good thing I handle situations like this so well. I really keep a cool head and just go with the flow.
All of these stages are wildly verbal and come with gobs of explanations to whomever might be with me when said change occurs (usually MB who is shell-shocked by my range in emotions…never a dull moment with me, right babe?). He, on the other hand, accepts change with calmness and perspective, he becomes quiet and considers things before reacting. While I’m having a melt-down like this:
He is more like this:
Maybe this behavior is based on my need for control (whaaaaaaat…yeah, I’m a little bit of a control freak) but could it also be a cultural difference? Could it be that my French husband handles change better than I do because of philosophical edification?
I mean, don’t get me wrong, I took philosophy at University so I guess I sort of know the basics but not like a French person. The French take philosophy to a whole new level. They have Descartes, Sartre, Camus…and that barely scratches the surface. For centuries they have been churning out one philosopher after another and, perhaps as a result, take the study more seriously.
Not long ago, during a visit from my Parents, MB happened to mention that when he was in high school Philosophy was a required class…required. My Mother (a teacher) erupted into surprised exclamations.
“PHILOSOPHY?!” She demanded.
“Philosophy?!” She questioned.
“Philosophy…in high school?” She queried.
MB gave her a Gallic shrug. “Oauis…c’est normale, non?”
Non, my little cabbage, not across the pond.
My experience was that philosophy was encouraged only in higher education but not considered an integral part of one’s academic life**. So, I took my requisite course and was taught about questioning everything….blah blah blah. However, it didn’t really take, my general reaction to philosophy was a sort of mild disgust:
“Why ask all these abstract questions? Can’t these people just make a decision already? I mean, all this dithering around, it’s exhausting! Just CHOOSE something! Yes or no, right or wrong!”
It seemed the pursuit of knowledge for knowledge’s sake was lost on me. I didn’t want to pursue knowledge, I wanted to know.
Absolutes are where my happy place is, which is, perhaps, why change unnerves me so completely. I don’t want a world full of questions and unpredictability. I am the person who checks the weather obsessively, plans detailed trips 6 months in advance, who rarely makes last minute plans or accepts last minute invitations. I like to know what is coming and to be prepared for it.
My philosophy: Why inquire when you can answer?
“You will never be happy if you continue to search for what happiness consists of. You will never live if you are looking for the meaning of life.”
When they finally called for our train, MB and I ran towards it and hopped into the car that was listed on our old tickets. However, since the train had changed, so had the seating, and our old seats didn’t exist (cue more panicking)
“This looks good, non?” MB said, pointing at two seats.
I looked around, frantic, trying to think if there was some way to beat the system, to be organized about this, but we were trapped. There were hoards of people getting on and it was only a matter of time before all the seats were gone anyway…so we sat. Every minute felt like an eternity, as one person after another was ejected from randomly found seats, such as ours, by rightful ticket-holders.
“We should have bought the new tickets, we should have just BOUGHT the new tickets.”
My blood-pressure was through the roof. Each new person who entered the train was a threat. Whilst I was internally losing it, MB was unpacking…seemingly certain that we would remain in our seats. How could this be? There was no way of knowing! We didn’t even know what we would do if we got booted off the train, we didn’t know where we would go or how we would get home.
So many questions and no way to have an answer.
I jumped when the doors to the train finally slammed shut, sweet relief flooding through me. It was unbelievable, we were sitting in the only two seats in our entire car that hadn’t been booked by someone else. We had made it…even though there hadn’t been a plan.
And what would have been the major drama if we hadn’t kept our seats? We would have sat in the aisles or by the bathrooms like all the other poor people packed on our train or we would have waited for the next one. As the denial/epiphany stage washed over me, I felt a great sense of calm. Perhaps in future, I should be more contemplative before having a melt-down, perhaps I should embrace the French philosophical perspective instead of going straight into panic-mode. I should start asking questions and searching for the meaning of life, drinking coffee and smoking cigarettes in cafés while reading Neitzsche…
Meh. Seems like a lot of trouble.
I may never bother in asking all the questions but perhaps I could manage to follow Camus’ advice and quit searching so hard for the answers. Afterall, there is one great American philosopher whose words I have always valued:
* There were, in fact, people flipping out at the Gare de Lyon but mainly just the ones who were trying to rush onto trains that were leaving, most of the others were pretty chill and calm.
** This was just my educational experience. I know there are people in the USA who study philosophy in high school or more intensively in college.
13 thoughts on “To Be or Not to Be…Why Ask the Question?”
I studied philosophy extensively at my fancy private run-by-hippies high school, and stuck with it afterwords, until I got to post/meta/hyper/modern/marx-ism where all they seem to be doing is spinning their wheels and arguing amongst themselves by attempting to bury each other in word salad.
Twas then I realized that Douglas Adams was the greatest human philosopher, for he wrote: “Perhaps I’m old and tired, but I think that the chances of finding out what’s actually going on are so absurdly remote that the only thing to do is to say, “Hang the sense of it,” and keep yourself busy. I’d much rather be happy than right any day. “
Ha – Hear hear! 🙂
I think Americans plan and try to be responsible for themselves and their loved ones. Your story above just happened to work out well; if you hear the stories of what probably (statistically) happens to the average person, you will realize your happy outcome was improbable. So don’t worry about trying to plan, that is an adult response.
Yes, I guess a big part of planning is a desire to avoid bad situations…the whole “raind day” scenario and I definitely think it is good to have an idea about what you want to happen. Now, I just need to figure out how to remain calm when things inevitably don’t work out the way I thought they would…sigh. 🙂
Always love your writing, girl. Keep it up!
Thanks friend! Can’t wait to see you in October…I assume??
All fingers crossed! Already bought my ticket, but my brother may get married in Nov. & plans may change.
This made me laugh.
Concerning high school subjects, it seems they take philosophy but less world literature than we do in high school.
I can go with the flow and make last minute plans but surely also identify with you. I have come to love my planner. I also think the anticipation of an event is half of the fun (I may be paraphrasing Anne of Green Gables).
Yes – I think that is it too, having something to look forward to! It makes the more monotonous moments of life more bearable. Oh, how I love Anne!
I love your panic scenario. I used to feel the exact same way. But after a life of “changed plans” I have learn to relax a little more. Of course, still closer to your reaction that MB. P.S. I love your writing. I can’t read a post without LOL or Crying….I know your stocked!
Yeah, I guess you and I have both gone in directions that we wouldn’t have imagined in College! Haha…crying, I still can’t watch Love Actually without bursting out laughing thinking of you.
The train from Paris to Blois has tickets but no reservations and despite the fact that there has been a seat for me every time I’ve taken it, I still have to arrive too early and spend my time panicking about the possibility of having to sit in the corridor. One thing you’ll learn in life, unfortunately, is that every time things seem to be going along hunky dory and you have perfect control, something comes along and sweeps the carpet from under your feet. Especially when you have children and even when they study philosophy in high school!
Haha, I have no doubt you are right! I can’t imagine how much of a panic case I’ll be if MB and I procreate. OH la la…but hopefully by then I will have learned my Zen-ness at that point. 🙂